AMEX Financial Review — Survival Story!



AMEX Financial Review

A few months ago I posted a story about someone who got FR’ed by AMEX. Here is her story:

How a Newbie Can “Earn” a Dreaded Amex Financial Review!

I received a letter from a reader and it was like a Deja Vu. I thought to myself immediately…

Now, this is a story all about how

My life got flipped-turned upside down…

No, it wasn’t in the story. But it was close enough.

Bob (not his real name) is a devoted AMEX user member. He’s had and churned them for about 10 years.

Bob is a full time student who has some odd jobs in the summer. He had two gold cards which he used to travel out of state with BA. Up until recently he had no problems with any of his AMEX cards aside from some fraud alerts that were easy to fix over the phone.

About two months ago, he received an invitation to apply for a 75K Amex Business Platinum card. Being a smart guy who knows better than to take the first offer thrown at him, he called and asked for the 100K bonus. And he kept calling until he got someone who gave him 100K.

Two weeks later, he got another invite for an AMEX Business Gold card with a 75K bonus. He applied and got approved.

Bob has a real, legit sole proprietor business for his summer days. He put down his own name as the name of the business. He also lives with his parents, and files a tax report as a dependent. I believe this is an important element that had contributed to his success story.

Where does it start getting interested, you’re asking? Right here.

He grabbed his RedCard and went to Target to meet his spending obligations on the AMEX Gold card as any responsible citizen would’ve done (LOL), but his swipes were denied. Both of them.

He called customer service and was told the system was being updated. Nothing unusual so far, as the same thing happened to me, and I’m sure hundreds if not thousands of others. Later that night, he went back and did three successful swipes. The fourth swipe resulted in an error.

So Bob called Customer Service and was transferred to the Fraud Department that told him he would need to speak to another “Senior” department that would be available tomorrow. Bob demanded to talk to a supervisor and complained. After a few back-and-forths alternated with a few long holds, he was finally told to try his swipes again.

He did and successfully made two more swipes. The supervisor then told him that everything had been taken care of and he was good to go.

Only he wasn’t.

Next morning, Bob received the dreaded call from AMEX that told him to call back. When he did, he was told that all his AMEX accounts had been frozen and that he would receive the follow up instructions by email.  Basically, they wanted to check his taxes and needed his authorization to do just that.

I checked my email and saw that they wanted to verify that I paid taxes last year and I need to fax in a form allowing them to check.

“You are a very unique case”

I usually do not appreciate being called unique by civilians. In the world of miles, points, and free travel, it invariably means crazy. In the world of AMEX Financial Reviews, however, it might mean there is a hope.

Bob called the person who was reviewing his case and explained that he was the part of the family business, that he was a dependant, and that they hadn’t filed their taxes yet anyway. The AMEX guy told him how unique he was and said he’d have to escalate to the manager. Then he came back and said nothing could be done, as the computer said no. Bob reasonably inquired if he at least could keep his personal accounts, and was told that once you’re outed, you’re gone. It wasn’t the exact words he received, but what the hell—I’m invoking my poetic license here.

Keep in mind, that there was another pickle. By the time these events unfolded, Bob hadn’t received his bonus 75K MR points yet. So he paid his balance immediately, and a few days later his 75K bonus arrived. He then paid all his outstanding balances and asked Amex to speed up the pending 15K points or something to his MR account. Took a few calls, but it was done. He then moved all his points out of MR and into airline accounts.

What happened next, I can only classify as a miracle. Here is what Bob has to say about that

All worked out.

I sent a letter to their executive offices and someone from there contacted me and said that they will let me keep one account open. Then they cancelled all my card except one Gold one and they didn’t touch my points.

I guess I was a unique case because I haven’t found any stories online of someone who survived this without filing taxes.

So for what it’s worth, yes, it’s a unique case, but it is possible to get from the eye of the AMEX hurricane in one piece. Even thought they did close most of his credit cards, they left him one, and he would still be able to apply for more, I believe. And honestly, since AMEX won’t give you the same sign up bonus beyond the first one — who cares? The point is… well, there are two points, I think.

  1. It might be that by calling Customer Service several times on the day he had swiped his card at Target, Bob might have brought unwanted attention to himself.
  2. It’s worth it to fight (write to the Executive Office, in this case) even though the odds seem improbable.



Want to know more about free travel hacks? Sign up for my weekly digest (top left) and don’t miss the good stuff.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

[…] AMEX Financial Review — Survival Story! by Lazy Travelers. If you’re doing manufactured spending with American Express and aren’t ready to survive a financial review (e.g having your taxes and income in order) you’re certifiably crazy. I have a legitimate business with legitimate expenses and I’m still weary of doing too much manufactured spending because of financial reviews. […]


I got my Amex gold when I was 19 and a full time student. After a significant amount of MS I was hit with a financial review within 3 months of getting the card. I hadn’t filed tax returns for the previous year since I didn’t work. Amex just wanted pay stubs from the last three months and bank statements. I faxed it all to them and in a few days I was good to go


LOL, I applied for 12 Different Amex Cards, and got approved. Obviously, I was flagged for FR. I lied about Income, having a business, EVERYTHING when applying. Should I bother sending in IRS form, or call it A Day, and move on to another bank? I wont lose Any Sleep either way…MS is just a Fun hobby for me.

Copyright © 2024 2013-2020 All Rights Reserved. 


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x